Audit and Risk
Trinity Foundation Audit & Risk Committee
The Audit & Risk Committee reports independently to the Trustees on all aspects of controls and risks. The main function of the Committee is to review the significant financial reporting issues and judgements made in connection with TDA’s financial statements and reports, and to review the scope and effectiveness of TDA’s internal controls, including financial, operational and compliance controls. The Committee works in cooperation with the University’s Audit Committee in the conduct of its work. The Committee’s terms of reference may be viewed here.
Members of the committee are Ms Claire Conroy (Chair), Ms Ciara Deans and Ms Mairead Devine.
Committee Members
Claire Conroy
Claire was appointed to the Trinity Foundation Audit & Risk Committee in 2019 and Chairs the Committee since January 2023. She was appointed as a Trustee in January 2023. Claire is currently responsible for Capital & Financial Management as well as Investment Management oversight at B-Flexion Fund Management (Ireland) Limited. Claire was previously a Senior Consultant at KB Associates from 2016 to 2021 where she advised investment managers on the establishment and ongoing compliance and operational requirements of Irish funds.
Prior to joining KB Associates, Claire worked with Davide Leone & Partners Investment Company LLP, a London based investment manager, where she was responsible for fund accounting and operations. Previously, she was part of the PwC Asset Management Group where she specialised in the audit of investment funds and fund service providers. Claire is a graduate of Trinity College’s Business School. She is a member of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in Ireland and holds a Professional Certificate in Investment Fund Services Risk Management.
Ciara Deans
Ciara was appointed to the Trinity Foundation Audit & Risk Committee in 2021. Ciara is Head of Strategy, Change and IT at the Insurance Institute. Prior to joining the Institute, Ciara held a number of consulting and insurance industry roles delivering business intelligence, pricing, and system and process change solutions across the UK and Irish markets. She has also held a number of insurance roles on representative councils at both Local and National level. Ciara is an Associate of the Chartered Insurance Institute (ACII) and a Chartered Insurer. She graduated in Management Science and Information Systems from Trinity College, Dublin.
Máiréad Devine
Máiréad joined the Trinity Foundation Audit & Risk Committee in 2021. Máiréad is an experienced leader in Risk Management, Regulatory Compliance and Governance in Financial Services - she is currently the Chief Risk Officer at BNY Mellon (Ireland), previously holding the role of Group Head of Compliance for Bank of Ireland. She has extensive prior experience within regulatory bodies, including the Central Bank of Ireland and the Bank of England and in professional services (PwC) in both the UK and Ireland. Máiréad was a non-executive director in IAASA and is a current Member of Faculty at the Institute of Banking and Insurance Institute of Ireland Certified Director programmes. Máiréad is a Chartered Director with the Institute of Directors and a graduate of Trinity College Business School.
Professor Gerard Mc Hugh
Gerard was appointed as a Trustee in January 2023 and also joined the Trinity Foundation Audit & Risk Committee in January 2023. He is a Fellow of Trinity College, Associate Professor of Accounting, and University Dean of Development. Gerard qualified as a Certified Accountant with the Dublin Office of Deloitte. He is a former Dean of Trinity Business School and teaches accounting, financial analysis and financial reporting.
Trinity Foundation Audit & Risk Committee – Terms of Reference
1. Objectives
1.1 The Audit & Risk Committee (the Committee) is a sub-committee of the Trinity Foundation (TDA) Trustees.
1.2 Its main objective is to assist the Trustees fulfil their functions by providing independent and timely advice on areas within its remit.
1.3 The main function of the Committee is to review the significant financial reporting issues and judgements made in connection with TDA’s financial statements and reports, and to review the scope and effectiveness of TDA’s internal controls, including financial, operational and compliance controls and ensuring a robust Risk Management Framework to identify, assess, manage and monitor all key risks, financial and operational and reputational taking account of the TDA’s key objectives.
1.4 The Committee shall work cooperatively with the Trinity College Audit Committee in the conduct of its work.
2. Membership
2.1 The Committee, which shall be appointed by the Trustees, shall comprise not less than three (3) members and not more than (5) as follows:
- Two Trustees of TDA
- At least one External Member
- At least one member of the Committee shall be a qualified accountant with experience of working in a financial environment.
2.2 The Chairperson of the Committee shall be a Trustee of TDA.
2.3 Membership of the Committee shall normally be for an initial term of three (3) years, with the possibility of an extension of a further three (3) years. The general aim is to change the membership from time to time to ensure an appropriate balance between continuity, experience and fresh perspectives.
3. Meetings and Quorum
3.1 The Committee shall meet on at least three occasions per annum. Other meetings as required shall be convened by the Chairperson.
3.2 TDA’s Director of Operations shall act as the Secretary to the Committee.
3.3 The quorum for meetings shall be two, one of whom shall be a Trustee. Committee members may participate in meetings by telephone or other electronic means by prior arrangement with the Committee secretary. Urgent business may be conducted by written procedure with the approval of all members.
3.4 The Committee may invite the Chief Advancement Officer or any other person to attend any meeting(s) of the Committee, as it may from time to time consider desirable, to assist the Committee in the attainment of its objectives.
3.5 The External Auditors shall attend meetings by invitation when the annual audit plan and the audited financial statements are being considered, or at their request for other items, bar the approval of the minutes.
3.6 The Committee may meet privately and shall arrange for a programme of separate and joint meetings with the Internal Auditor and the External Auditors.
3.7 The Chairperson shall present a written report to the Trustees, prior to the submission of the annual financial statements to the Trustees, summarising the work of the Committee in the previous year. Additionally, the Chairperson shall report to the Trustees the Committee's views in relation to the audited financial accounts.
3.8 The Internal Auditor shall attend meeting(s) of the Trustees at the request of the Committee and/or the Trustees.
3.9 The draft minutes of the Committee shall be circulated to the Trustees as soon as possible for noting and/or discussion as necessary. The Chair of the Committee shall be available to report orally to the Trustees on key aspects of the proceedings of the Committee as required. In the event of matters which in the opinion of the Committee are of an urgent and/or serious nature, the Chair of the Committee shall bring these to the attention of the Trustees as soon as practicably possible.
4. Duties
4.1 Financial Reporting
Reviewing and challenging where necessary, the actions and judgements of management in relation to the annual financial statements before submission to the Trustees, taking account of the results of the annual audit and any advice and information supplied by the External Auditors.
4.2 Internal Control and Risk Management
Review TDA’s governance arrangements, internal controls systems and Risk Management Framework and processes to identify, assess, manage and monitor key risks and report to the Trustees accordingly. At least twice a year review, challenge and approve the full TDA risk register.
4.3 Compliance
Oversee the process for ensuring compliance with legislative and regulatory requirements and TDA policies and relevant code of practice adopted by the Trustees. Reviewing and advising the Trustees, where appropriate, in its consideration of any compliance statement required.
4.4 Internal Audit
Reviewing and approving the internal audit annual plan, including the degree of co-ordination with the external audit plan. Reviewing internal audit reports and findings and seeking to ensure the implementation by management of significant recommendations. Monitoring and reviewing, at least annually, the effectiveness of the Internal Audit arrangements, seeking to ensure that it is independent and free from management or other restrictions.
4.5 External Auditors
- Making recommendations to the Trustees on the appointment, re-appointment and removal of the External Auditors.
- Approving, following input it deems appropriate from management, the remuneration and terms of engagement of the External Auditors in respect of the provision of audit services to TDA, liaising as appropriate with the College’s Audit Committee.
- Reviewing with the External Auditors their plan for their audit of the TDA's financial statements.
- Reviewing the results of the external audit, including:
- Any problems which may have been encountered by the External Auditors and the degree of co-operation received.
- Significant recommendations to management in the management letters and management's response.
- Monitoring the performance and quality of the services provided by the External Auditors.
- Reviewing their qualifications, independence and objectivity annually, taking into consideration all relationships between TDA and the External Auditors.
- Monitoring the engagement of the External Auditors to supply non-audit services taking into account relevant legal requirements and guidance regarding the provision of non-audit services by the External Auditors and the provision of audit related services by other audit firms, considering their expertise and value for money.
- Monitoring the External Auditors' compliance with relevant statutory or regulatory requirements.
5. Authority
- Approve the internal audit annual plan.
- Approve the remuneration and terms of engagement of the External Auditors in respect of the provision of audit services to TDA and approve the selection process to be followed.
- Approve the carrying out of non-audit services by the External Auditors.
- Approve the appointment, remuneration and terms of engagement of the Internal Auditors in respect of the provision of internal audit services to TDA.
The Committee is authorised to seek any information it requires from any employee of the TDA to enable it to discharge its responsibilities and shall have made available to it on a timely basis all information requested from any employee in a clear, concise and well-organised manner.
6. Performance Evaluation
The Committee shall, on a biennial basis, arrange for the review of its performance and its terms of reference and shall report its conclusions and recommend any changes it considers necessary to the Trustees.